| Name | Species | Position or description |
| Sasha | Human | The remaining survivor of the
previous Coincidence #8. |
| Athena | Human | The leader of The Pantheon,
or Coincidence #4. |
| Prometheus | Human | Member of the Pantheon,
bound to a Fire Spirit named Frrrrrshkkkkk. |
| Cerberus | Furry | The Pantheon's tracker,
bioengineered with wolf genes. |
| Ares | Human | The Pantheon's combat
specialist. |
| Hecate | Human | The Pantheon's primary
spellcaster, a Wiccan priestess. |
| Hermes | Demon-Blood | The Pantheon's
jack-of-all-trades and combat driver. Can run/fly at paranormal
speeds. |
| Holmes | Human | The presumed leader of
Coincidence #9. |
| Tyco | Ghoul | Coincidence #9's combat
specialist, and a licensed Paranormal Private Investigator. |
| Ezra | Human | Coincidence #9's primary
spellcaster, a Jewish rabbi with a penchant for chaotic
magic. |
| Lillian | Demon-Blood | a former succubus,
and Coincidence #9's most mysterious member. |
| Mr. Hiro | Ghost | A 17th century samurai bound
to his katana, who works with Coincidence #9. |
| Katie | Furry | A priestess of Bast, biologically
altered with primarily cat genes, and Coincidence #9's
second spellcaster. |
| John Cole | Human | Coincidence #9's
technical expert; helped design the Labyrinth. |
